Enigma Scale

Pay Per Click

What PPC management costs, and what the fee should cover

VAVignesh AravindCo-founder, Performance and Design
Published |Updated |6 min read
Hands on a laptop keyboard reviewing paid ad campaign performance in a dark office
Table of contents

Ask three agencies to quote on the same ad account and the fee models will not even match each other, let alone the numbers. One quotes a percentage of spend, one a flat monthly retainer, one a price per campaign. Comparing them feels like comparing three different products, because in effect you are.

Below is how we see the market pricing management in Australia, the four things that move a quote up or down, and the questions that separate a considered proposal from a template.

The three ways agencies price management

Nearly every proposal you receive uses one of three structures, and each one shifts whose interests the fee serves.

  • Percentage of spend. Usually 10 to 20 percent, sliding down as budgets rise. Simple to understand and it scales, but it rewards the agency for spending more of your money rather than spending it better. Ask what happens to the fee if they cut your spend in half and hold revenue flat.
  • Flat monthly retainer. Typically $1,500 to $5,000 for a mid-sized account across one or two platforms. The fee is tied to the work rather than the budget, which is the cleanest alignment of the three. It is also the model most likely to be under-resourced without anyone saying so, so ask for the hours.
  • Hybrid, or a base plus performance. A smaller retainer with a bonus attached to a defined outcome. Sensible when the outcome can be measured cleanly and the definition is written by you rather than the agency.

Percentage models tend to look cheaper at small budgets and expensive at large ones. Flat fees do the reverse. If a quote sits far outside these bands, the difference usually comes down to scope rather than generosity.

Monthly PPC management fees
Under $1kMaintenance only
$1.5k to $3kEntry level
$3k to $5kMost mid-sized
$5k and aboveEnterprise
Where most mid-sized accounts belongEnigma Scale

What the fee bands buy

Money buys senior hours, and everything else follows from that. Here is what each band can realistically staff, based on how we see agencies resource accounts at each level.

Monthly feeTypical scopeWho it suits
Under $1,000Templated management, mostly automated bidding, a monthly report generated from the platformA single small local campaign with little competition. For anything competitive it buys maintenance, not management
$1,500 to $3,000A real specialist on the account part-time, structured testing, weekly search term work, landing page feedbackA business with real competitors bidding against it; this is the floor for that situation
$3,000 to $5,000Multiple platforms, creative production, conversion tracking that survives an audit, a senior person who will tell you when to stop spendingMost mid-sized accounts
$5,000 and aboveMulti-market work, feed management, incrementality testingLarge product catalogues, several markets, or categories where a single lead is worth five figures
Fee bands reflect our own view of the Australian market, not a published survey.

What moves the price

Four variables account for nearly all of the spread between quotes on the same account.

How many platforms you are running

Search alone is a different job from search plus shopping plus paid social plus retargeting. Each platform adds its own creative requirements, bidding logic and reporting surface. Two platforms done properly beats four done thinly, and a good agency will tell you that before you ask.

How many products or services you sell

A five-service business needs a handful of campaigns. A ten-thousand product catalogue needs feed management, automated campaign structures and someone who understands merchant data, which is a materially larger job. If that is you, the state of your product feed attributes will shape the quote as much as the catalogue size.

Whether creative is included

On paid social especially, creative is the lever that moves performance most and the line most often left out of a quote to hit a price point. If ad production is excluded, you either supply it or the campaign stalls.

Who is doing the work

A senior strategist costs several times what a junior running a checklist costs. Seniority is the thing most often swapped out without comment to win a price comparison, and the most damaging over a year.

What a properly managed account gets each month

If you are paying somewhere in the mid band, this is a fair expectation of what lands.

  • A named specialist you speak to directly, not an account manager relaying questions
  • Review of the search terms report and placements often enough that waste is caught in weeks rather than quarters
  • Structured testing with a written hypothesis, not shuffling ad copy for the sake of activity
  • New creative in rotation on any platform where fatigue is real
  • Landing page and offer feedback, because a large share of paid problems are conversion problems
  • Conversion tracking checked and reconciled against your own numbers, not taken on faith from the platform
  • Reporting in cost per acquisition and revenue, with impressions and clicks as supporting detail

If a proposal cannot show you where those hours go, ask before signing. Our PPC management service is scoped around this list, and it is a fair yardstick for any agency's proposal.

Signs a quote is too cheap

Underpricing is a scope decision made without telling you which parts were cut. Watch for these.

  • A guaranteed cost per lead or a guaranteed position, neither of which anyone controls
  • No mention of conversion tracking setup or verification anywhere in the proposal
  • Creative excluded entirely on a paid social engagement
  • Reporting that stops at clicks and impressions and never reaches revenue
  • A different person on every call, or no named contact at all
  • A twelve month lock-in with a break fee, which moves the risk of underperformance onto you

Working out what management is worth to you

The argument gets easier once the number is derived rather than guessed. Take your current cost per acquisition and your monthly spend. As an illustration, a manager who improves efficiency by twenty percent on a $20,000 monthly budget returns $4,000 of media value every month. Against a $3,000 fee that is already positive, and efficiency gains compound as the account gets cleaner.

Then look at the opposite risk. On the same illustrative budget, an untended account losing thirty percent of its spend to irrelevant search terms is wasting $6,000 a month. The fee is rarely the expensive part of paid media. The wasted clicks are. If you are still deciding whether paid search suits your business at all, run the three tests for whether Google Ads will work before comparing fees.

Questions to ask before you sign

These five separate a considered proposal from a template.

  • Who works on the account day to day, and how many hours a month do they spend on it?
  • What did you find in our account before writing this proposal, and what would you fix in week one?
  • Is creative production included, and if not, what do you need from us?
  • Which metric are we judged on, and who decides whether it moved?
  • What happens to our accounts, data and conversion history if we leave in six months?

That last one matters more than it looks. Your ad accounts and conversion history should be owned by you and accessed by the agency. In Google Ads that means your business holds admin access to the account and grants the agency its own login. If it does not, changing supplier means starting over.

The short version

Expect 10 to 20 percent of spend or $1,500 to $5,000 a month for a mid-sized account, judge the proposal on where the hours go rather than the number at the bottom, and treat any guarantee of a specific cost per lead as a reason to ask harder questions. Cheap management is rarely cheap. It moves the cost into the media budget, where it is harder to see, and getting more from Google Ads starts with stopping that leak.

VA
Vignesh Aravind
Co-founder, Performance and Design at Enigma Scale

Vignesh runs paid media, social and design at Enigma Scale. He has managed spend across every major ad platform and rebuilt the sites those clicks land on, which is usually where the real problem turns out to be.

More from Vignesh →

Keep reading on Pay Per Click

All Pay Per Click posts →

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top